Doctor Who is back and brilliant!

The Woman Who Fell to Earth, the introduction to Jodie Whittaker’s take on Doctor Who, premiered yesterday, and (for my spoiler-free review) it was utterly fantastic!

I’ve not had enough time to process to really put together a coherent review, so I’ll just call out a few highlight notes (spoilers below):

  • I dig the companions. They all feel like real, genuine, earnest, down to earth people, instead of the near gods that some other companions have been (The Girl Who Waited, The Impossible Girl, etc). I’m reminded of Donna Noble, except before she became the most important being in the entire universe. I hope that these people just stay good people on their adventure, instead of ascending.
  • On the topic of the friends, the unexpected death of Grace really hit me hard. I don’t know why I didn’t see it coming since I had heard there were three companions this season and the Doctor immediately had four friends but… yeah, it hurt. I would not be sad to see an alternate timeline version of that character poke her head back in somewhere in episode seven or so.
  • On to the Doctor! Jodie Whittaker is utterly and completely fantastic! I love the absent-mindedness of her dialog, I love that she’s a tinkerer, I love that she is immediately kind and empathetic… she is 100% The Doctor. And more than that, she embodies that character completely and immediately from her first frame, more than other regenerations have. I am totally in.
  • The lack of a theme song or TARDIS (or end credits, thanks BBCA) was super off-putting, and really made this feel like something different. Obviously, we are going to get those components soon, but it reminded me of the start of Star Trek Discovery, which spends two episodes basically on a prequel story before the show actually kicks off. I think this works lovely as an introduction to the series, but I suspect we’ll get more of a feel for the day-in-day-out format of the new show next week.
  • Finally, one last thought. Why did she have her friends hold on to all those pieces of the transporter at the end? Couldn’t that car battery have been sitting on the ground? Is there any chance that maybe, just maybe, she wanted to bring them along?

3 responses to “Doctor Who is back and brilliant!”

  1. Had a chance to watch it last night. I will hold my opinion of the new Doctor until I have seen a few episodes. I am not entirely sure if it was, from what I heard, a lot of editing for BBC America to fit in commercials, but as a first episode it was ok. I am thinking back and right now she feels on par with Peter Davison. And I am willing to give her a good shot in the role. Davison followed Tom Baker and that was certainly a tough act to follow. As someone who has watched the series for a long long time, I have to admit I had a “Wait what did she just say about buying clothes?” Something along the lines of “It’s been a long time since I’ve had to buy clothes as a woman” And my first thought was oh great they are going to Retcon the series to lead newer viewers to believe the Doctor in one past life was a woman. Granted William Hartnell was supposed to be the 2nd doctor, but we saw the episodes recently where the 1st doctor was revealed. I don’t even wan to fall down the 13th regeneration rabbit hole. I will give it a chance like I have all the others. But right now? On the fence.


    1. BBCAmerica definitely did some unacceptable garbage editing on this episode to make commercials work, which really ruined the pacing throughout.

      As far as the Doctor goes, it’s definitely too early to make an overall decision on how she fits in, but for me she clicked way faster than anyone else in NuWho.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. There have been a few over the years when PBS was not running episodes where I looked at the guy as the Doctor and thought wait they played the Doctor? I was not much of a McCoy fan, and the 8th and 9th I cant say I really recall. Per tweet I think they limited by having him stuck on Earth. At least they are working at continuing the series. Hope she does well.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: